Our Services

Get 15% Discount on your First Order

[rank_math_breadcrumb]

Discussion 2

500 word response 2 references/intext citations

Due 1/15/2025

Major Question Doctrine

A recent and critically important administrative law doctrine is being established by the US Supreme Court over the last 5 years culminating in the case of 

Biden v. Nebraska site.
 where the high court struck down the US Department of Education’s regulations forging portions of their student loan debt.  Here is some commentary on the “Major Questions Doctrine” as to its application to the student loan case decision:

This major question doctrine can be articulated here  
Major Questions Doctrine.pdf

This major question doctrine was solidified within case law in the landmark USSCT decision in 
West Virginia v. EPA (2022) found in our textbook on page 548  It explains in detail a “major question” and how that preempts an administrative agency’s decision making on a certain topic/issue. 

1. Explain the “Major Question Doctrine” in your own words and explain if this new doctrine swallows up the “rule” that administrative agencies are given great deference in their decisions on interpretations and implementations of the legislative acts; and

2. Would it be ethical for the US Department of Education to continue its attempts for such loan forgiveness regulations?  Pick one of the below ethical theories assigned to the first letter of your last name (Ethical Relativism), explain it, then apply it to the facts of this case and conclude under it if it is moral/ethical to forgive such student loans?  You will have to do some independent research on each of the below ethical theories online to learn about them and how they work.

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

Criminal Justice

RESPONSE TO EACH POST WITH 150 WORDS Response #1 The research process is complex, presenting unique challenges at each stage. Among these, the literature review stage is particularly challenging. This crucial phase requires synthesizing an immense body of scholarly work, which is the backbone of the research project. The task

Criminal Justice

The first “article report” assignment, which is due this week, is about “Introduction” section of research. For this assignment, you need to find THREE articles (three peer-reviewed articles in the field of criminology and criminal justice) and read their Introduction section and report what was the main question of the

Response 2 5439

300 word response1reference/intext citation Due 1/17/2025 Amrita  Explain how Aristotle’s Doctrine of the Mean works differently from Ethical Relativism and if Ethical Relativism would result in a different conclusion if the administrative agency is acting ethical or not in passing such a new regulation.    2. Applying Aristotle’s Doctrine of

Response 1 5439

300 word response1reference/intext citation Due 1/17/2025 Ronnie Explain how Machiavellianism works differently from Ethical Relativism and if Ethical Relativism would result in a different conclusion if the administrative agency is acting ethical or not in passing such a new regulation.    In my opinion, I tend to favor strongly with libertarian

Post 2.1

P2 Q2 200 word response 1 reference/intext citation Due 1/17/2025 Ronae Circumstantial physical evidence can provide more information that direct evidence could be missing making it preferred or more reliable than direct evidence. In certain scenarios where direct evidence is unavailable, circumstantial physical evidence can help the investigation by establishing

Post 2

P2 Q2 200 word response 1 reference/intext citation Due 1/17/2025 Carol The Role of Circumstantial Evidence in Investigations  Circumstantial evidence becomes very important in investigations where direct evidence does not exist. One of the relevant cases that demonstrates this is the 2004 case of Scott Peterson being convicted for the

Post 1.1

P1 Q1 200 word response 1 reference/intext citation Due 1/17/2025 Elliot When agencies compete for control over the same investigation, mechanisms like the establishment of lead agencies, interagency protocols, or the appointment of special counsels are essential are critical. Ensuring investigative integrity requires clear communication. In addition, role delineation and

Post 1

P1 Q1 200 word response 1 reference/intext citation Due 1/17/2025 Jean In this hypothetical case, two state police agencies who form an arson task force are at odds with the perpetrator’s motives. Motives are classified into two classes; robbery, rape, and burglary are considered first class, which doesn’t usually have

Discussion

Describe the different types of search patterns and what would make you choose one over another. What aspects need to be included in performing a good search? Look at the PowerPoint labeled Search Patterns and Principles and include what search patterns you would use for the scenes shown and include

Ethics

Imagine you are part of a community task force aiming to develop a new initiative for crime prevention that effectively incorporates ethical practices and cultural perspectives. Create a presentation video that outlines your initiative, detailing its goals, target audience, and the ethical implications of your approach. Include elements such as

Patriot Name Search

 Judgment Lien Search – Charles Jones; Providing certified judgment lien search services for any time period up to 20 years. As little as 24-hour turnaround.

Week 2 Help

Please see Two Attachments Instructions · See ATTACHED ARTICLE to complete an article critique · 2 Pages in length · APA format · Must contain the three parts below 1. Summary: After completing the assigned readings ask yourself: What are the main arguments? What is the point this book/article/chapter is

Article Assistance

Please see three attachments! Discussion Post Instructions: · At least 250 words…do not go over 500 words!! · Answer the following based on the articles attached! · What are some advantages that community policing offers? Why? · What are some disadvantages? Why? · What is your response to the articles?

Response 2.2

100 word response 1 reference/intext citation Due 1/10/2025 Shroeder Post 2 Q2: The orientations of trying to prove a case and uncovering the truth aren’t necessarily different. If investigators coexist, between both, it takes balance. The main goal should be uncovering the truth. Uncovering the truth despite the tension is

Response 2.1

100 word response 1 reference/intext citation Due 1/10/2025 Epps Post 2 Q2: Investigators often face tension between striving to prove a case and uncovering the truth. Are these orientations fundamentally different, or can they coexist within investigative work? Choose one orientation, explain your perspective, and use a real or hypothetical

Response 1.2

100 word response 1 reference/intext citation Due 1/10/2025 Schroeder Post 1 Q1: “Reconstructing the past” intersects with investigative methods by piecing together events, memories, and behaviors to make a timeline. This allows us to understand what happened before, during, and after. Technologies aid this process. For example, forensic analysis, surveillance,