Our Services

Get 15% Discount on your First Order

[rank_math_breadcrumb]

CASE STUDY 3.2 Project Selection at Nova Western, Inc. Phyllis Henry, vice president of new product development, sat at her desk trying to make sense of the latest new project proposals she had just r

CASE STUDY 3.2

Project Selection at Nova Western, Inc.

Phyllis Henry, vice president of new product development, sat at her desk trying to make sense of the latest new project proposals she had just received from her staff. Nova Western, Inc., a large developer of business software and application programs, had been experiencing a downturn in operating revenues over the past three quarters. The senior management team was feeling pressure from the board of directors to take steps to correct this downward drift in revenues and profitability. The consensus opinion was that Nova Western needed some new product ideas, and fast.

The report Phyllis was reading contained the results of a project screening conducted by two independent groups within the new product development department. After several weeks of analysis, it appeared that two top contenders had emerged as the optimal new project opportunities. One project, code-named Janus, was championed by the head of software development. The other project idea, Gemini, had the support of the business applications organization. Phyllis’s original charge to her staff was to prepare an evaluation of both projects to decide which one Nova Western should support. Because of budget restrictions, there was no way that both projects could be funded.

The first evaluation team used a scoring model, based on the key strategic categories at Nova Western, to evaluate the two projects. The categories they employed were: (1) strategic fit, (2) probability of technical success, (3) financial risk, (4) potential profit, and (5) strategic leverage (ability of the project to employ and enhance company resources and technical capabilities). Using these categories, the team evaluated the two projects as shown here. Scores were based on: 1=low, 2=medium, and 3=high.

  project Janus and project gemini

category                                                      importance             scores                        weighted score

                                                             janus      gemini          janus     gemini            janus      gemini

1. strategic fit                                             3       3                    2           3                       6              9

2. probability of technical success          2       2                   2             2                      4               4 

3. financial risk                                            2       2                    1              2                    2               4

4. potential profit                                         3       3                    3             3                   9                9

 5. strategic leverage                                    1       1                    1              2                  1               2    

     score of Janus= 22

      score of Gemini=28

The results obtained by this first team suggested that Project Gemini would the best choice for the next new project.

The second team of evaluators presented an NPV analysis of the two projects to Phyllis. In that analysis, the evaluators assumed a required rate of return of 15% and an anticipated inflation rate of 3% over the life of the project. The findings of this team were as follows:

Project Janus                                                                                                               Project Gemini

    initial investment= $250,000                                             Initial investment= $400,000

    life of the project= 5 years                                                  life of project=3 years

   anticipated stream of future cash flows:                            anticipated stream of future cash flows:

    year 1 = $50,000                                                                     Year 1= $75,000

    year 2 = 100,000                                                                      year 2 = $250,000

    year 3= 100,000                                                                        year 3= $300,000

    year 4 = 200,000                                                                        calculated NPV = $25,695

    year 5 = 75,000

calculated NPV = $60,995

Thus, according to this analysis, Project Janus would be the project of choice.

The analyses of the two projects by different means yielded different findings. The scoring model indicated that Project Gemini was the best alternative, and the financial screening favored the higher projected NPV of Project Janus. Phyllis, who was due to present her recommendation to the top management team in the afternoon, was still not sure which project to recommend. The evaluations seemed to present more questions than answers.

Questions

  1. Phyllis has called you into her office to help her make sense of the contradictions in the two project evaluations. How would you explain the reasons for the divergence of opinion from one technique to the next? What are the strengths and weaknesses of each screening method?
  2. Choose the project that you think, based on the two analyses, Nova Western should select. Defend your choice.
  3. What does this case suggest to you about the use of project selection methods in organizations? How would you resolve the contradictions found in this example?

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

Week 4 Writing Assignment After reading the Week 4 material, we know that change in the fire service is inevitable. Without change, people and organizations would become stale and unresponsive. Th

Week 4 Writing Assignment After reading the Week 4 material, we know that change in the fire service is inevitable.  Without change, people and organizations would become stale and unresponsive.  The challenge is to learn how to steer through the transition as easily and creatively as possible.  To successfully navigate the

DISCUSSION Most managers believe that while it is possible to connect logistics decisions to costs, the connection to revenue enhancement is difficult to impossible. Do you agree or disagree? Why? To

DISCUSSION Most managers believe that while it is possible to connect logistics decisions to costs, the connection to revenue enhancement is difficult to impossible. Do you agree or disagree? Why? To earn full credit, post an initial response of 500 words that includes at least one APA citation and the

week 4 DISCUSSION “In today’s competitive business environment, effective logistics management is essential to maintaining operational efficiency and customer satisfaction. How do demand management, o

week 4 DISCUSSION “In today’s competitive business environment, effective logistics management is essential to maintaining operational efficiency and customer satisfaction. How do demand management, order management, customer service, inventory management, and facilities location interact to influence a company’s overall logistics performance?  Can you identify a real-world example where optimizing one

WEEK 5 TO DO DISCUSSION The purpose of the discussion question is to allow you to demonstrate your understanding of the unit’s key learning points and how you might apply them in a given situation. Pa

WEEK 5 TO DO DISCUSSION The purpose of the discussion question is to allow you to demonstrate your understanding of the unit’s key learning points and how you might apply them in a given situation. Participating in the discussion question forum provides you with an opportunity to compare your ideas

DISCUSSION Discuss whether corporate cultures are relevant to supply chain management. In your post, ensure to give concrete examples (you may use Starbucks as your example and assess its supply chain

DISCUSSION Discuss whether corporate cultures are relevant to supply chain management. In your post, ensure to give concrete examples (you may use Starbucks as your example and assess its supply chain or you may use another company as an example). To earn full credit, post an initial response of 500

Week 1 to do DISCUSSION Explain how technological advances have contributed to the increased importance of logistics. In your post, ensure to include at least two solid examples showing the impact of

Week 1 to do DISCUSSION Explain how technological advances have contributed to the increased importance of logistics. In your post, ensure to include at least two solid examples showing the impact of technology on your experience as a consumer.  To earn full credit, post an initial response of 500 words

Pick and clearly describe (in about a paragraph) a situation (preferably but not necessarily in business) that requires a decision necessitating a decision tree with at least two branches, each branch

Pick and clearly describe (in about a paragraph) a situation (preferably but not necessarily in business) that requires a decision necessitating a decision tree with at least two branches, each branch having at least two sub-branches. In another paragraph explain and justify the structure of the decision tree you are

Socio-Cultural Considerations Choose a city in another country (outside the United States). Research tourism in that country, and answer the following questions: Give a small synopsis on the history a

Socio-Cultural Considerations Choose a city in another country (outside the United States). Research tourism in that country, and answer the following questions: Give a small synopsis on the history and demographics of the country. What are the socio-cultural considerations for that country? What is the current climate of tourism in

Unit Outcomes: Describe occupational safety and health regulatory organizations such as OSHA.Describe the function and oversight of occupational safety and health organizations.BI100-5: Describe emplo

Unit Outcomes: Describe occupational safety and health regulatory organizations such as OSHA. Describe the function and oversight of occupational safety and health organizations. BI100-5: Describe employer role in addressing safety in the workplace. Purpose For this assignment, you will use the Reflection Template to provide a reflection on what the readings, learning activities,

Unit 9 Assignment: Addressing Workplace Safety ConcernsOutcomes addressed in this activity: Unit Outcomes: Apply lean safety measures to promote safety.Describe the employer’s role in addressing safet

Unit 9 Assignment: Addressing Workplace Safety ConcernsOutcomes addressed in this activity: Unit Outcomes: Apply lean safety measures to promote safety. Describe the employer’s role in addressing safety concerns in the workplace. Present the safety recommendations to address a safety concern. Use appropriate APA formatting and citations in scholarly writing. BI100-5: Describe

****** THIS ASSIGNMENT HAS 6 PARTS / PLEASE LABEL EACH PART SEPARATELY WITH REFERENCES WHEN COMPLETED****** **** HUMANITIES COURSE **** PART 1- Module 6 – DISCUSSION A Comparable Development Pr

****** THIS ASSIGNMENT HAS 6 PARTS / PLEASE LABEL EACH PART SEPARATELY WITH REFERENCES WHEN COMPLETED****** **** HUMANITIES COURSE **** PART 1- Module 6 – DISCUSSION A Comparable Development  Prompt: Pick one of the developments mentioned in The Renaissance or one of the developments mentioned in The Enlightenment. Then think of

Module 3 – SLPHarnessing the Power of Operations and FinanceAssignment Overview Accounting and Finance Strategies We will address organizational performance from a money perspective. How do accounting

Module 3 – SLPHarnessing the Power of Operations and FinanceAssignment Overview Accounting and Finance Strategies We will address organizational performance from a money perspective. How do accounting and finance functions support a company’s goals and help it move forward according to plan? SLP 3 Resources Contribute to an Ethical Culture (2022) DEI

Module 3 – CaseHarnessing the Power of Operations and FinanceAssignment Overview Strategic Management As your final written case of class, it is time to complete all of the connections regarding how

Module 3 – CaseHarnessing the Power of Operations and FinanceAssignment Overview Strategic Management  As your final written case of class, it is time to complete all of the connections regarding how strategy is implemented in an organization and the roles of the stakeholders across functional areas. Case 3 Resources Corporate-Level