Our Services

Get 15% Discount on your First Order

[rank_math_breadcrumb]

Response 1

200 word response 1 reference/intext citation

Due 2/7/2025

Hicks

Respond to the post and explain how Utilitarianism works differently than Ethical Egoism and if Ethical Egoism would result in a different conclusion if the administrative agency (DBPR)  is acting ethical or not in revoking the business license and liquor license under these facts.  

Utilitarianism is an ethical theory that evaluates actions based on their consequences, emphasizing the greatest good for the greatest number (Mill, 1863). According to utilitarianism, an action is considered ethical if it maximizes overall happiness and minimizes harm. Act utilitarianism assesses each action’s direct impact, while rule utilitarianism considers whether the action aligns with rules that generally promote overall well-being. Applying utilitarianism to DBPR’s decision requires weighing the potential benefits and harms of revoking the business’s licenses.

From DBPR’s perspective, the agency may argue that its actions serve the public interest by enforcing laws that maintain “decency” in entertainment, particularly in venues accessible to minors. By shutting down the business, DBPR might claim that it is upholding moral standards and responding to community concerns. Additionally, the state may justify the action as part of broader efforts to regulate businesses and ensure compliance with laws governing public performances. However, these potential benefits must be weighed against the extensive harm caused by DBPR’s actions.

The revocation of the business’s licenses results in immediate economic harm, including job losses for employees and financial strain on the business owners. Additionally, this action sets a dangerous precedent for censorship of unpopular or minority expressions, creating a chilling effect on free speech. It disproportionately impacts LGBTQ+ communities, reinforcing social discrimination and marginalization. The enforcement also imposes legal costs on both the business and taxpayers, as Florida will likely face prolonged litigation, given that similar laws have already been struck down in federal court. Since DBPR’s action does not provide significant societal benefits and instead results in economic, social, and legal harm, the decision fails the utilitarian test. The negative consequences outweigh any perceived benefits, making DBPR’s actions unethical from a utilitarian perspective.

Thus, applying utilitarianism, in my opinion, DBPR’s enforcement is morally unjustified, as it causes more harm than good. The revocation of business licenses suppresses free expression, undermines economic stability, and disproportionately harms marginalized communities without a compelling public benefit. The principle of maximizing happiness and minimizing harm suggests that allowing the business to operate freely would result in a greater overall benefit to society.

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

III

See both attachments Instructions: Answer the 5 discussion questions corresponding to exercise 2.1, and the three application exercise questions corresponding to exercise 2.2, in the uploaded Ireland et al., pdf (Ireland et al., Chapter 2 & application exercises). Students are simply asked to offer a complete answer to each question.

D9 posc

Why have third parties never really taken off in America? Would you like to see a third party alternative to the Democrats and Republicans? If yes, what would you look for in such a party? Do you think the Democrats and Republicans will ever face a viable third party challenge?

crj 435 wk8 i need help

CRJ435 – Drugs, Gangs, and Organized Crime Week 8 Activity – Local and Global Gangs Worksheet Local and Global Gangs 1. Describe a gang operating in your area, including its name, location, and 3 facts about the gang. Note : These facts could relate to the gang’s: · History ·

crj 331 i need help wk1

CRJ331: Common Disorders in the Criminal Justice System Overview: The goal of this activity is to reinforce the facts around some of the more common disorders seen in the criminal justice system by forensic psychologists. Each disorder has a flashcard with a brief definition from the American Psychiatric Association and

Write a reflection

Write a reflection on the following uploaded material. In the reflection include a summary of the key points and answer these questions What are the key takeaways from this week’s materials? How do the materials connect to your experiences, current events, or previous course content?What aspects did you agree or

DB Response

Please see attached.  CJUS 350 Discussion Assignment Instructions The student will complete 8 Discussions in this course. The student will post one thread of at least 400 words by 11:59 p.m. (ET) on Thursday of the assigned Module: Week. The student must then post at least 2 replies of at

Political S

1. Educational System and Infrastructure One of the most immediate challenges African countries would face in rejecting European languages is the existing educational infrastructure. For decades, African nations have built their educational systems around European languages, and a significant portion of scholarly research, textbooks, and educational resources are in these

2-2 Journal: Juvenile Versus Adult: Integrity, Authority, and Discretionary Power

Please review the attachment below for assignment details. Module Two Journal Assignment Guidelines and Rubric.html CJ 230 Module Two Journal Assignment Guidelines and Rubric Overview In this assignment, you will explore the roles integrity, authority, and discretionary power play when addressing an adult defendant and a juvenile defendant. Prompt Now

Excel 1G Regional Sales

Sheet1 The Easy Pantry Regional Sales to Specialty Stores Quarter 1 Quarter 2 Quarter 3 Quarter 4 Total % of Total Sales Trend Northeast 325465.5 410758.22 452877.24 485326.27 Southeast 295784.87 301875.43 320983.47 335752.43 West 489624.81 466233.87 469987.54 522874.66 Total Sales

Criminal Justice

Article review must be: 1. At least two pages not including reference page. 2. Very clear and understandable summary 3. All scholarly (peer reviewed articles or law reviews) that clearly support or refutes the conclusion. APA Must have at least 3 references.

WK 4 DB

Please see attached. CJUS 350 Discussion Assignment Instructions The student will complete 8 Discussions in this course. The student will post one thread of at least 400 words by 11:59 p.m. (ET) on Thursday of the assigned Module: Week. The student must then post at least 2 replies of at

Criminal Justice

Discussion instructions Each discussion must be 250 words. Each discussion question must have two references. Outside references are all scholarly (peer reviewed journal article, law review) in APA format.

Disc 9

Is it ethical to call domestic and international terrorist enemy combatants rather than criminals?  What are some of the issues that may arise?

question, week 2 dp

Under what circumstances do officers act “under the color of law,” and why is it important to understand this? Will community policing increase or decrease the number of civil liability claims? Policing in minority communities is often challenging. Please explain why and what can be done to establish confidence in

week 3

Week 3 – Can you identify at least two obstacles to the initial crime analysis movement and how these obstacles impeded the evolution and advancement of crime analysis to date? Identification, prevention, and the proactive reduction of community crime are contingent upon access to timely accurate information. Data driven management

DB Response

Please see attached.  CJUS 350 Discussion Assignment Instructions The student will complete 8 Discussions in this course. The student will post one thread of at least 400 words by 11:59 p.m. (ET) on Thursday of the assigned Module: Week. The student must then post at least 2 replies of at

Module One Practice Activity- CJ 305 Technology in Criminal Justice

Please see attachment below for assignment details. Module One Practice Activity Guidelines and Rubric.html CJ 305 Module One Practice Activity Guidelines and Rubric Overview In this assignment, you will explore technological tools and police goals. You will examine the different ways to classify law enforcement technology and the police goals