please check below
Argument analysis discussion (give remarkable replies to west, ju, and Ant arguments) philosophy.
a. West Gag Lop
1. Vaccinations are a touchy subject, considering that many people think that these vaccinations do more harm than good. It states in the article (
to an external site.
) that getting vaccinated is safer than getting sick. It also states that the immune response of the body to a vaccine may cause tiredness and discomfort for a day or two.
2.
Position : Getting a vaccine is morally better than getting sick and is better in the long run.
3.
Agree:
· Premise 1 : The resulting protection of a vaccine can last a lifetime.
· Premise 2 : Vaccines help the body learn how to defend itself from diseases
· Premise 3 : Your body learning to defend itself from diseases is morally better than being sick.
· Conclusion : Therefore, Getting a vaccine is morally better than getting sick and is better in the long run.
Disagree :
· Premise 1 : The bodily immune response to a vaccine may cause tiredness and discomfort for a couple of days.
· Premise 2 : Since the vaccine causes tiredness and discomfort then it is morally wrong to get the vaccination.
· Conclusion : Therefore, It is morally wrong to get the vaccination since it hurts you in the process.
b. Ju M Kelley
1. Domestic violence is a heavy topic, meaning it is very hard to explain certain aspects of it that could never be justified. “A pattern of behavior used by someone to control their intimate partner. The behavior includes abusive threats and actions that may or may not be criminal. The behaviors may include physical, emotional, financial and sexual abuse.”
Start the Conversation: Be a Better Ally | Office for the Prevention of Domestic ViolenceLinks to an external site.
2. Position: Domestic violence is as moral as they come. Between the start of it to the finish, it can get very tricky. You have to understand that there are different forms of domestic violence and that every form has a lasting impact on the victim even it is a man, a woman, a child, or even an elder.
3. Agree
Premise 1. All forms of domestic violence is morally wrong.
Premise 2. 1 in 4 women and 1 in 10 men have experienced some form of DV. (Domestic Violence)
Premise 3. Coming forward to get justice is harder than it looks and taking the next step requires courage some people will never have. Taking the strength and courage by abusing and misusing someone’s trust make it hard for anyone to seek help when needed.
Disagree
Premise 1: Each DV case varies, some cases are stickily he said, she said, some cases either party doesn’t want to prosecute, and some cases have no evidence supporting the claim.
Premise 2: After following the process in court, prosecutor might find no grounds to incriminate, and the case will be dismissed. Especially if the victim decides to file a non-prosecution affidavit even if they said they wanted to press charges in the first place. I don’t think that’s right as in the moment they’ve could’ve been scared for their life and then between that and court, they could’ve been pressed to waive the charges.
c. Ant
1. Match-fixing within sports, has become a controversial topic in today’s world. Many believe it takes away from the authenticity and trust from the sport, while others believe it brings more drama and excitement.
2. Position: Match-fixing sports games to create excitement is morally bad.
3. Agree
Premise 1: Authentic sports games are exciting and competitive on their own.
Premise 2: interfering and creating an unfair advantage to make the games more exciting is cheating.
Premise 3: Cheating is bad.
Conclusion: Therefore, Match-fixing sports games to create excitement is morally bad.
Disagree
Premise 1: people pay a lot of money to go see exciting games that turn out boring.
Premise 2: Match-fixing creates more excitement for the games.
Conclusion: Therefore, it is morally permissible to match-fix sports games.
