Our Services

Get 15% Discount on your First Order

[rank_math_breadcrumb]

by tomorrow ?

PHIL 347 Critical Reasoning

Week 5 Guided Learning Activity: Relevance and Fallacies

Directions: Type the letter answer into Canvas. You may also include the whole line. The letter

comes before the line or sentence

Example:

[A] Paris is the biggest city in France. [B] It is a major cultural center with many famous

museums. [C] The most famous of these museums is the Louvre.

In this passage, A = Paris is the biggest city in France. B = It is a major cultural center with many

famous museums. C = The most famous of these museums is the Louvre.

Section 1: Relevance

Fallacies are mistakes in reasoning. Before we can spot mistakes, we need to understand what

counts as relevant. A positively relevant claim gives a reason to believe something. A negatively

relevant claim gives a reason not to believe something. Read pages 122–124 before starting this

section.

Passage:

The issue is whether Jamal should buy an electric bike

[A] Jamal enjoys cycling for exercise and commuting.

[B] His city has limited bike lanes, making some routes unsafe.

[C] He recently bought a new car that he rarely drives.

[D] Jamal works long hours and sometimes struggles to find time for exercise.

[E] The local bike shop is offering a discount on electric bikes this month.

[F] Friends who own electric bikes say they make commuting faster and less tiring.

[G] His apartment building has limited storage space for bicycles.

Question 1: Line A is

a. Positively relevant

b. Negatively relevant

c. Irrelevant

Question 2: Line B is

a. Positively relevant

b. Negatively relevant

c. Irrelevant

Question 3: Line C is

a. Positively relevant

b. Negatively relevant

c. Irrelevant

Question 4: Line D is

a. Positively relevant

b. Negatively relevant

c. Irrelevant

Question 5: Line E is

a. Positively relevant

b. Negatively relevant

c. Irrelevant

Section 2: Getting Personal

Critical thinking requires separating a person’s argument from the person themselves. While

we’re wired to evaluate people, this can get in the way of evaluating logic. Review pages 125–

130 before starting.

Passage:

[A] Don’t subscribe to StreamPlus — the CEO wears designer suits and obviously doesn’t care

about regular people.

[B] Also, their most popular competitor, FlixZone, has had a few outages, so maybe all

streaming services are unreliable.

[C] StreamPlus claims that its algorithm recommends the best shows, but you are sure to get

viruses that will steal your identity

[D] StreamPlus’s low prices are just designed to rope you in. Later, they will increase prices.

[E] Try CineWorld instead — sure, it loads more slowly sometimes, but at least it didn’t crash

during last night’s premiere.

Question 6: Line A is

a. Ad hominem

b. Attacking the motive

c. Look who’s talking (tu quoque)

d. Two wrongs don’t make a right

e. Scare tactics

Question 7: Line B is

a. Ad hominem

b. Attacking the motive

c. Look who’s talking (tu quoque)

d. Two wrongs don’t make a right

e. Scare tactics

Question 8: Line C is

a. Ad hominem

b. Attacking the motive

c. Look who’s talking (tu quoque)

d. Two wrongs don’t make a right

e. Scare tactics

Question 9: Line D is

a. Ad hominem

b. Attacking the motive

c. Look who’s talking (tu quoque)

d. Two wrongs don’t make a right

e. Scare tactics

Question 10: Line E is

a. Ad hominem

b. Attacking the motive

c. Look who’s talking (tu quoque)

d. Two wrongs don’t make a right

e. Scare tactics

Section 3: Changing the Subject

Straw man and red herring fallacies twist arguments or distract from the issue. Read pages 132–

133 before continuing.

Dialogue:

Taylor: We should encourage visitors to use reusable containers instead of disposable plastic at

the beach to reduce pollution.

Morgan: (A) So you want to make everyone bring their own containers and ban ice cream

cones? That’s extreme.

Taylor: (B) No, just suggesting alternatives to single-use plastics for snacks and drinks.

Morgan: But even if we reduce plastics, seagulls will still scatter trash everywhere—it won’t

really solve pollution.

Taylor: (C) Honestly, the bigger issue is that people leave food wrappers behind, which attracts

wildlife. That’s what we should focus on.

Morgan: (D) You’re just trying to change the subject from the real problems, like overcrowded

beaches and insufficient lifeguards.

Taylor: (E) The goal is to reduce plastic waste; that doesn’t mean ignoring other beach

management issues.

Question 11: Line A is

a. Straw man

b. Red herring

c. Neither

Question 12: Line B is

a. Straw man

b. Red herring

c. Neither

Question 13: Line C is

a. Straw man

b. Red herring

c. Neither

Question 14: Line D is

a. Straw man

b. Red herring

c. Neither

Question 15: Line E is

a. Straw man

b. Red herring

c. Neither

Section 4: Fallacies of Evidence

These fallacies involve improper use or interpretation of evidence. Read pages 143–154 before

doing this section.

Dialogue:

Lee: I think installing smart thermostats in our apartment building could save energy and reduce utility

bills.

Jordan: (A) If we install a few smart thermostats, soon every appliance will be automated, and we’ll lose

control over everything in our homes!

Lee: That’s not the case. Smart thermostats can be managed individually and don’t take over other

devices.

Jordan: (B) If smart thermostats really saved energy, don’t you think all buildings would already have

them? don’t save energy.

Lee: Studies show that smart thermostats generally help reduce energy usage when programmed

correctly.

Jordan: (C) Last month, my neighbor installed a smart thermostat and the heating bill went up, so these

devices clearly

Lee: (D) So either we don’t install anything, or our building will be fully automated and out of control

Jordan: (E) A few people I know who installed smart devices have had constant tech problems, so all

smart home tech must be unreliable.

Question 16: Line A is

a. Appeal to ignorance

b. Post hoc fallacy

c. Hasty generalization

d. Slippery slope

e. False alternative

Question 17: Line B is

a. Appeal to ignorance

b. Post hoc fallacy

c. Hasty generalization

d. Slippery slope

e. False alternative

Question 18: Line C is

a. Appeal to ignorance

b. Post hoc fallacy

c. Hasty generalization

d. Slippery slope

e. False alternative

Question 19: Line D is

a. Appeal to ignorance

b. Post hoc fallacy

c. Hasty generalization

d. Slippery slope

e. False alternative

Question 20: Line E is

a. Appeal to ignorance

b. Post hoc fallacy

c. Hasty generalization

d. Slippery slope

e. False alternative

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

Peer response

  The development of advanced practice nursing roles globally shows how important quality and safety competencies are in guiding practice. When looking at the variability in education, regulation, and scope of practice across countries, it becomes clear that standardized competencies are essential to ensure safe and consistent care (Wheeler et

nursing

see file In this two-part deliverable assessment, first, create a 5–7 slide elevator-speech style presentation that you will present to stakeholders that provides an overview of policy implementation, including rationale and data that reflect the need for the new policy. Second, create a detailed, annotated training agenda for the pilot

nursing

see file Propose an organizational policy and practice guidelines that you believe will lead to an improvement in quality and performance associated with the benchmark underperformance you advocated for improving in Assessment 1. Be precise, professional, and persuasive in demonstrating the merit of your proposed actions. The policy proposal requirements

case study

Nursing Skills & Reasoning © 2023 KeithRN LLC. All rights reserved. No part of this case study may be reproduced, stored in retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of KeithRN Blood Transfusion 1. Which

casestudy

Nursing Skills & Reasoning © 2023 KeithRN LLC. All rights reserved. No part of this case study may be reproduced, stored in retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of KeithRN Blood Transfusion 1. Which

CASE STUDY ANALYSIS

PLEASE READ ALL ATTACHED Week 2 Case Study Prompt  A 28-year-old African American woman presents with 4 months of worsening fatigue, joint  pain, and intermittent low-grade fevers. She reports: • Symmetrical pain and stiffness in hands and wrists (morning stiffness ~1 hour) • Photosensitivity • Facial rash that worsens with

STRENGTHS AND LIMITATIONS OF SECONDARY DATA SOURCES

find attached n use the rubrics In this information age, where data are readily accessible and there is both a great demand for accelerated research projects and strict limitations on research funding, using existing data makes sense. Data used in this way are called secondary data; they come in many

Evaluation and Management

Evaluation and Management (E/M) Insurance coding and billing is complex, but it boils down to how to accurately apply a code, or CPT (current procedural terminology), to the service that you provided. The payer then reimburses the service at a certain rate. As a provider, you will have to understand

EBP

Module 7:  Research Project As a DNP, you have been asked to identify why the patients that are undergoing surgery are complaining that pain experienced after a surgical procedure has not been managed adequately. The patients’ need of narcotics is around the clock until the pain subsides. The lack of

Home work

Determine the linear correlation and regression equation between two variables to make predictions for the dependent variable. Project Deliverable tie to Competency  In this assignment, you will demonstrate your understanding of how relationships between two variables can be analyzed and used to make informed predictions. By interpreting scatter plots, conducting

DESCRIPTIVE EPIDEMIOLOGY: DATA SOURCES AND DATA COLLECTION

Diabetes is a significant public health challenge in the United States, with Table 3.2 identifying Hemoglobin A1C levels, incidence of skin infections, obesity, peripheral neuropathy, and renal insufficiency as key measurable outcomes (Curley, 2024). The population selected for this discussion is Hispanic/Latino adults in the United States, a group disproportionately

Community Health

Please see attached. Create a slide presentation of the health promotion plan you developed in Assessment 1. Complete the following: · Prepare a 12–14 slide PowerPoint presentation with detailed speaker notes that reflects your presentation. This presentation is the implementation of the plan you created in Assessment 1. The speaker

Scholarship For Nursing practice

It is anticipated that the initial discussion post should be in the range of 250-300 words. . All posts should be supported by a minimum of one scholarly resource, ideally within the last 5 years. Journals and websites must be cited appropriately. Citations and references must adhere to APA format.

Week 1 clinic skills

Rate yourself according to your confidence level performing the procedures identified on the Clinical Skills Self-Assessment Form.   Based on your ratings, summarize your strengths and opportunities for improvement.    Based on your self-assessment and theory of nursing practice, develop three to four (3–4) measurable goals and objectives for this practicum experience. Include them on the designated area of the form.   

The future of Nursing

It is anticipated that the initial discussion post should be in the range of 250-300 words. Substantive content is imperative for all posts. All discussion prompt elements for the topic must be addressed. Please proofread your response carefully for grammar and spelling. All posts should be supported by a minimum

Psychopharmacology Discussion Week 1 reply

 Need a response Epigenetics and Gene Expression Epigenetics serves as the regulatory switch for gene expression by modifying chromatin structure without altering the underlying DNA sequence. This system determines how tightly DNA is wound around proteins called histones. When chemical tags like methyl groups are added (methylation), the chromatin condenses,

Psychopharmacology Discussion Week 1 reply TG

Need a response  Main Post As I have been working through my advanced healthcare degree and taking classes such as advanced pharmacology and now psychopharmacology, I have started to see how signal transduction really brings the “why” behind medications to life, especially when I think about mental health treatments. Ion