Our Services

Get 15% Discount on your First Order

[rank_math_breadcrumb]

Case Study Assignment: William Dillon The William Dillon case (1981–2008) highlights multiple failure points we’ve studied—especially misapplied forensics (dog scent “science”), eyewitness error, inf

Case Study Assignment: William Dillon

The William Dillon case (1981–2008) highlights multiple failure points we’ve studied—especially misapplied forensics (dog scent “science”), eyewitness error, informant incentives, and official misconduct. Do an AI deep dive or thorough Google search to learn more, then answer the questions below. 

AI Use:  Sanctioned – Use AI or search tools to find sources and learn about the case. Unsanctioned – Using AI to draft your answers.Write in your own words and cite sources.

Case Study Questions:

1) Definitions

  • Was William Dillon factually innocent?
  • Does this case illustrate a wrong-person conviction, a no-crime case, or something in between?

2) History

  • Where does Dillon’s case sit within the broader timeline of wrongful convictions we studied (e.g., Borchard’s catalog, pre-DNA practices, rise of the Innocence Movement)?
  • How did post-conviction DNA testing change the landscape compared with earlier eras?

3) Prevalence

  • Considering estimates that 0.5–5% of felony convictions may be wrongful, what does Dillon’s case suggest about the risk from small-sample forensic methods (e.g., dog scent, bite marks)?
  • How might official secrecy or lost evidence contribute to undercounting wrongful convictions?

4) Process and Production

  • Identify failure points at each stage: investigation (focus on Preston’s testing), charging, trial (eyewitness + informant + dog scent), appeals, post-conviction.
  • What gatekeeping should have been applied to Preston’s methods (Daubert/Frye factors such as validation, error rates, peer review, standards)?

5) Causes and Correlates

  • Which causes from our reader are most evident (misapplied forensics, mistaken ID, informants, official misconduct, inadequate defense resources)?
  • Explain precisely how each cause manifested here using concrete details from the record.

6) Forensics Focus

  • Briefly explain how a dog-scent lineup is supposed to work and why it is scientifically controversial. What did courts and experts later conclude about John Preston’s methods?
  • Contrast the dog-scent claims with the DNA results from the T-shirt. What does this reveal about hierarchies of scientific reliability and the need to preserve testable evidence?

7) Impact and Effects

  • How did the wrongful conviction affect Dillon (time served, re-entry, compensation, stigma)?
  • What are the broader community effects when the actual perpetrator isn’t held accountable?

8) Summary

  • What is the single most important lesson from Dillon’s case for preventing wrongful convictions today?
  • Propose one concrete policy you would implement (who does it; how it will be measured).

Submission

Upload your completed Case Study Assignment to the Case Study 2: William Dillon assignment folder no later than Sunday, 11:59 p.m. Include citations and link to primary sources when possible.

Starter Sources (expand beyond these):• National Registry of Exonerations — William Dillon (case narrative, evidence timeline).• Innocence Project and Innocence Project of Florida — case pages, litigation updates.• Court filings and orders related to vacatur and dismissal; news coverage of DNA testing on the T-shirt.• Scholarly/forensic critiques of dog-scent lineups and testimony.

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

Create a literature review of 10 sources in order to refine and validate the questions for the questionnaire QUESTIONNAIRE ATTACHED. Submission Instructions: The literature review is to be clear and

Create a literature review of 10 sources in order to refine and validate the questions for the questionnaire  QUESTIONNAIRE ATTACHED. Submission Instructions: The literature review is to be clear and concise and students will lose points for improper grammar, punctuation, and misspelling. The literature review should be formatted per current APA

Reflect critically on the strengths and weaknesses of this module’s readings in regards to inequality and privilege. Include your view on the ideas put forth in the lecture materials.3 pages (not incl

Reflect critically on the strengths and weaknesses of this module’s readings in regards to inequality and privilege. Include your view on the ideas put forth in the lecture materials. 3 pages (not including the reference page, no title page needed). READINGS : Barak, G., Leighton, P., & Cotton, A. (2018).

1ST PAPER: Chapter 1 & 2 Reflect critically on the strengths and weaknesses of this module’s readings in regards to crime control and criminology. Include your view on the ideas put forth in the

1ST PAPER: Chapter 1 & 2  Reflect critically on the strengths and weaknesses of this module’s readings in regards to crime control and criminology. Include your view on the ideas put forth in the lecture materials. 3 pages (not including the reference page, no title page needed). Submission Instructions: The

Part 2: You will write a critical review that synthesizes your reactions to the two articles. Your paper must be APA style (e.g., title page, no abstract, double-spaced, reference page). The paper sho

Part 2: You will write a critical review that synthesizes your reactions to the two articles. Your paper must be APA style (e.g., title page, no abstract, double-spaced, reference page). The paper should be 800-1000 words. Please use the following organization. The first section should include a general summary of the studies

Many agree that cannabis prohibition in the US has done much more harm than good. Fischer et al. underscore several important research areas which might yield evidence important for constructing polic

Many agree that cannabis prohibition in the US has done much more harm than good. Fischer et al. underscore several important research areas which might yield evidence important for constructing policy aimed at reversing some of the harms from prohibition. Which of these areas seemed most important to you? Moreover,

Alternative Research Assignment: Writing Assignment on Peer Reviewed Article. Guidelines for paper. This assignment is submitted in two parts. Both parts are submitted directly to your instructor. Eac

Alternative Research Assignment: Writing Assignment on Peer Reviewed Article. Guidelines for paper. This assignment is submitted in two parts. Both parts are submitted directly to your instructor. Each part is equivalent to two hours of research credit (25 points for each part, in order to achieve a total of 50

The “Marihuana” tax act, along with the Harrison Narcotics Act, were not born from careful examination of an accumulation of evidence. Indeed, the strong opinions of reformists, and a cabal of powerfu

The “Marihuana” tax act, along with the Harrison Narcotics Act, were not born from careful examination of an accumulation of evidence. Indeed, the strong opinions of reformists, and a cabal of powerful “anti-druggist” physicians and state and federal legislators were the primary catalysts for complete prohibition. Using context and examples

Research Question: What is the effectiveness of current airport personnel training for active shooter situations in enhancing readiness, and how can existing programs be improved? This section descr

Research Question: What is the effectiveness of current airport personnel training for active shooter situations in enhancing readiness, and how can existing programs be improved? This section describes the design of the applied/creative project and situates the project within an issue, question, or problem within the discipline. For this week’s

For this assignment, you will focus on a case, and complete the first three steps of the critical thinking process: 1) Identification, 2) Research, and 3) Analysis. First, read the Guardian Article: “

For this assignment, you will focus on a case, and complete the first three steps of the critical thinking process: 1) Identification, 2) Research, and 3) Analysis. First, read the Guardian Article: “Social media bans for teens: Australia has passed one, should other countries follow suit?”:  to an external site. (Note,

Minipapers (2). You are required to complete 2 “minipapers” of your choosing during the course of the semester. Minipapers must be at least 2 pages but should not exceed 3 pages of text, not including

Minipapers (2). You are required to complete 2 “minipapers” of your choosing during the course of the semester. Minipapers must be at least 2 pages but should not exceed 3 pages of text, not including title page, references, tables, graphs, and other ancillaries. Submissions must be double-spaced and use 12- point Times New Roman

In this assignment, you evaluate and assess workplace protection legislation, identify the law pursuant to the employment-at-will (EAW) doctrine and legal exceptions, apply this understanding to a bus

In this assignment, you evaluate and assess workplace protection legislation, identify the law pursuant to the employment-at-will (EAW) doctrine and legal exceptions, apply this understanding to a business scenario, and explain legal requirements for hiring new employees and your own home state laws as to workers’ compensation and immigration. Instructions

Research Question: What is the effectiveness of current airport personnel training for active shooter situations in enhancing readiness, and how can existing programs be improved? For this week’s as

Research Question: What is the effectiveness of current airport personnel training for active shooter situations in enhancing readiness, and how can existing programs be improved? For this week’s assignment, you will write the Project Design section of your capstone. This section describes the design of the applied/creative project and situates

Discussion Estate planning is one of those things people don’t really need until they REALLY need it. Ideally, a client would come in and have all necessary documents prepared far before his or her

Discussion  Estate planning is one of those things people don’t really need until they REALLY need it.  Ideally, a client would come in and have all necessary documents prepared far before his or her actual demise, but real life is messy.  In Virginia, all divorce decrees are required to have language about

Apply the following corrections. Please see the example of what I am looking for attached below. Overall, while the topic is highly relevant and well-researched, the literature review suffers from in

Apply the following corrections.  Please see the example of what I am looking for attached below. Overall, while the topic is highly relevant and well-researched, the literature review suffers from inconsistencies in writing quality, structure, synthesis, and citation formatting that weaken its scholarly impact. A proper graduate literature review should