Our Services

Get 15% Discount on your First Order

[rank_math_breadcrumb]

Criminal Justice

SAMPLE CASE BRIEF
Follow this format (except type double spaced). Your brief should be no more than
two or three double-spaced pages.
=============================================================

NEAR V. MINNESOTA, 283 U.S. 697 (1931) [complete name of case, citation, date]
decision by Supreme Court of United States [name of court issuing the opinion]

FACTS: J. M. Near published the Saturday Press in Minneapolis. In a series of articles he
charged, in substance, that a Jewish gangster was in control of gambling, bootlegging and
racketeering in the city, and that the city government and its law enforcement agencies and
officers were not energetically performing their duties.

A Minnesota statute (referred to as a “gag law” provided for the abatement, as a public
nuisance, of a “malicious, scandalous and defamatory newspaper, magazine or other periodical.”

Near was cited as being in violating of this law and brought into court. An injunction was
issued by a district court that halted all activity of the Saturday Press. Near was prohibited from
ever publishing the newspaper again unless he could convince the court that he could operate a
newspaper free of objectionable material.

Near appealed this ruling. The Minnesota Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of the
law, holding that under its broad police power the state could regulate public nuisances, including
defamatory and scandalous newspapers. The U. S. Supreme Court granted Near’s petition for
certiorari.

LEGAL QUESTION: Is the action by the state of Minnesota against the newspaper (a
prior restraint) a violation of Near’s Fourteenth Amendment rights, which guarantees that “no
state shall deprive any person of life, liberty or property, without due process of law”?

DECISION: Yes. (5-4, Chief Justice Hughes wrote the majority opinion.)

COURT’S RATIONALE: The Minnesota statute is not designed to redress the wrongs of
the individuals who have been attacked by Near. Instead, it is directed at suppression of the
offending newspaper or periodical and puts the publisher under an effective suppression. The
object of the law is not punishment but suppression, and not only of the offending issue but of all
future issues as well. The statute is not consistent with the conception of liberty of the press as it
has been historically conceived and guaranteed.

It is true that the principle as to immunity from previous restraint is stated too broadly; this
immunity is not absolutely unlimited. But the limitation has been recognized only in exceptional
cases. These cases include (1) certain utterances during wartime, (2) the publication of obscene
matter, (3) or material that incites acts of violence and the overthrow by force of orderly
government.

However, there are occasions in which limiting freedom of the press to only freedom of
prior restraint is not enough. Punishment after publication can impose a kind of prior restraint
upon the individual. A citizen must have the right to criticize government — without fear of
punishment.

DISSENTING OPINION: (written by Justice Butler, joined by Justices Van Devanter,
McReynolds and Sutherland)

The dissent argued that the majority decision gave freedom of the press too broad a meaning
and scope. Justice Butler argued that the Minnesota statute applied only to those engaged in the
business of regularly and customarily publishing “malicious, scandalous and defamatory

newspapers,” not to newspapers in general. The Minnesota statute was passed as part of the
state’s police powers, and there exists in the Minnesota a state of affairs that justifies this measure
for the preservation of peace and good order.

SIGNIFICANCE OF THE CASE: The case establishes the precedent that the press is to
be protected against prior restraint by the government except in exceptional situations. It was also
the first case involving newspapers in which the Supreme Court applied the provisions of the
First Amendment against states through the language of the Fourteenth Amendment
(incorporation of free press guarantees into those liberties that states may not abridge without due
process of law).

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

7-2 Project Two

Please see the attached below for assignment details. CJ 230 Project Two Template Memo to the Judicial Ethics Advisory Committee Complete this template by replacing the bracketed text with the relevant information. To: Judicial Ethics Advisory Committee From: [Your Name] Date: [Date] Subject: Discretionary Actions of Judge I am the

CJ 305 Project Three

Please see the attached below for assignment details. Project Three Guidelines and Rubric.html CJ 305 Project Three Guidelines and Rubric Competency In this project, you will demonstrate your mastery of the following competency: Analyze the criminalization of technology Scenario Someone has come into your station to file a police report.

week 3 discussions 535

discussions  2 discussions 250 word minimum Discussion 1 Why is the concept of the time value of money important for making long-term project decisions? Discussion 2 250 word minimum In a line item budget, you begin with initial inflationary adjustments only in an effort to explain how much is required

week 3 discussions 510

Discussion  2 discussions 250 word minimum Discussion 1 In Chapter 6, the authors provide two scenarios relating to lying within the criminal justice system. Box 6.1 focuses on police interrogations based on the case of  Miller v. Fenton . Box 6.2 is focused on the ethics of plea bargaining with

Law – Criminal 5-1 Module Five Assignment: Impact of Cybercrime

Please see attached below for assignment details. Module Five Assignment Guidelines and Rubric.html CJ 305 Module Five Assignment Guidelines and Rubric Overview In this assignment, you will explore cybercrime. You will examine the Target data breach and evaluate its impact on both the individuals and the business. Prompt In this

5-2 Project One Submission

Please see attached below for assignment details. Project One Guidelines and Rubric.html CJ 305 Project One Guidelines and Rubric Competency In this project, you will demonstrate your mastery of the following competency: Describe technological tools that are used in criminal justice Scenario As a newly hired police officer, you have

CJ 305 Project Two

Please see the attached below on assignment details. Project Two Guidelines and Rubric.html CJ 305 Project Two Guidelines and Rubric Competency In this project, you will demonstrate your mastery of the following competency: Analyze considerations for implementation and use of technology in professional practice Scenario You have been working at

510 discussions week 2

discussions 2 discussions 250 word minimum Discussion 1 Chapter 4 introduces the ethical schools of thought and the Masters of each school. Select one school of thought and its Master(s). (Do not choose Utilitarianism (Bentham) or the Ethics of Duty and Reason (Kant), as we will discuss those schools and

535 week 2 discussion

discussion post 2 discussions 250 word minimum Discussion 1 Financial statement analysis is an important assessment tool for businesses; however, what value does ratio analysis provide for budgeting in the public sector, and why is it beneficial for a criminal justice manager to understand how and why these ratios are

week 1 discussions

discussions 2 discussions 250 word minimum Discussion 1 There are three budgeting formats that are used in the budgeting process: line item, performance, and program. Discuss the value/benefits that each format contributes to the budget process. Discussion 2 Of the three budget formats, line item, performance, and program, which format

Discussion

Discuss some of the issues involved in equipment purchases.  What are the direct costs, the reoccurring costs and indirect costs that you can think of. Discussion the impact of budget costs on a Lab and the direct and indirect effects on other submitting Agencies.  If your costs go up where

Write a reflection

Write a reflection for the following sources attached. Must answer the following questions:  [Provide a concise summary of key points from all assigned materials.] Critical Thinking [Analyze and connect the materials using these guiding questions: What are the key takeaways from this week’s materials? How do the materials connect to

Create a visual presentation

create a visual presentation using your preferred program (e.g., Canva, PowerPoint). This project aims for you to creatively express your understanding of the book, its connection to our learning materials, and propose policy recommendations for improving the criminal justice system. Throughout, you should include visuals (images, illustrations, icons) that enhance

Sab 1

Why is the United States the only western industrialized nation to routinely employ capital punishment?

CJ 230 Module Five Practice Activity

Please see the below attached for details Module Five Practice Activity Guidelines and Rubric.html CJ 230 Module Five Practice Activity Guidelines and Rubric Overview In this practice activity, you will identify the steps of the decision-making process within a scenario. You will then craft an objective summary of the decision-making

Law – Criminal CJ 230 Module Six Assignment

Please the attached below for details. Module Six Assignment Guidelines and Rubric.html CJ 230 Module Six Assignment Guidelines and Rubric Overview In this assignment, you will explore how laws can limit or rely on discretion, and how aspects of an agency’s culture can influence discretion. Prompt In Module Four, you learned

CJ 230 Module Six Practice Activity

Please see attached below for details. CJ 230 Module Six Practice Activity Template Discovery in a Court Case Complete the table below by replacing the bracketed text with the relevant information. Court Case in APA Format Role of Discovery Discovery and Discretionary Decisions Discovery and Documentation [Insert text.] [Insert text.]