CRITICAL ANALYSIS In a minimum 750-word essay, compare/contrast “The Pit and The Pendulum” by Edgar Allan Poe and “In the Penal Colony” by Franz Kafka in terms of the different torture technologies

CRITICAL ANALYSIS

In a minimum 750-word essay, compare/contrast “The Pit and The Pendulum” by Edgar Allan Poe and “In the Penal Colony” by Franz Kafka in terms of the different torture technologies and the legal systems they represent. Be sure to address the following questions in your analysis:

1. What symbolic dimensions do the torture technologies depicted in each story have? For instance, why do the Inquisitors try to push the protagonist/narrator into a pit in Poe’s story? Also, what could be the symbolic meaning of the pendulum torture? In Kafka’s story, why are the drawings used in the apparatus for the inscription of the sentence illegible to the human eye? Also, what could be the meaning of the apparatus’s malfunctioning at the end of the story?

2. How is the idea of injustice suggested in each story? What details, what procedures given in the stories would make us conclude that both Poe and Kafka are depicting legal systems that are fundamentally unjust? Give specific examples from the texts.

For this assignment, you are required to formulate and develop a critical thesis statement, rather than state what is evident in a text or your personal impressions about it.

Examples of inadequate thesis statements:

– “The statements of the protagonist-narrator in ‘The Pit and the Pendulum’ show that he has suffered greatly in the dungeon.”

– “‘In the Penal Colony’ by Franz Kafka is a creepy story.”

– “‘In the Penal Colony’ and ‘The Pit and the Pendulum’ are similar but also different in many ways.”

Example of an acceptable thesis statement:

“The variety of sensory details used in ‘The Pit and the Pendulum’ reinforces the subjective experience related by the protagonist-narrator and thus contributes to the story’s atmosphere of horror.”

For further clarification about how to write a good thesis statement and build an essay based on that statement, consider the following formulae:

“X is/isn’t Y” – poor thesis statement

“X achieves Y through Z” – strong thesis statement

Furthermore, you must use at least one scholarly source (a peer-reviewed article, a scholarly book, etc.). Please do not regard this requirement as an unnecessary hassle. Especially if you have no idea how to answer the questions above, reading what expert critics have written on these works will help you immensely. If you do not know how to do research on scholarly sources, please consult the friendly librarians at Fanshawe Library–they would be more than happy to assist you with your research.

I do not wish to bother you with compliance to a specific documentation style (such as MLA or APA). If you readily know how to use any such style, use it. If you don’t, just be sure to indicate your source(s) at the end of your essay AND use page numbers, quotation marks and phrases referring to the respective author(s) in the body section of your paper, in order to distinguish between ideas and sentences that are your own, and those that come from other sources. Basically, do what I do in my lecture slides. If you need further help on this point, please let me know.

Share This Post

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

T & D Project – In the BUS 393 Training & Development course, the assignment titled “Integrating Training and Development Strategies into Organizational Success” serves as the main project for

T & D Project – In the BUS 393 Training & Development course, the assignment titled “Integrating Training and Development Strategies into Organizational Success” serves as the main project for the semester, emphasizing the application of concepts from Raymond Noe’s “Employee Training and Development” (9th edition) to real-world scenarios. THIS

Create an Internet Marketing Plan for your event or to market yourself as an event planner for your final project topic. You may refer to general guidelines described this week’s assigned text reading

Create an Internet Marketing Plan for your event or to market yourself as an event planner for your final project topic. You may refer to general guidelines described this week’s assigned text readings. Some questions to consider: How will you advertise? Where will you advertise? What is your target market?

OBJECTIVE: Using analytical, rhetorical, and digital skills, you will design a website argument based on your selected pop culture + social issue. Your website will digitally reimagine Classical (Aris

OBJECTIVE: Using analytical, rhetorical, and digital skills, you will design a website argument based on your selected pop culture + social issue. Your website will digitally reimagine Classical (Aristotelian) Argument structure, which has 5 parts and a Works Cited: Grab the Audience’s Attention Use your argumentative claim/thesis as the title of your site. Grab

This research and citation exercise measures your mastery of ULO 3.1. Your Expository Essay assignment requires that you use at least one academic source from the CSU Online Library, so this assignme

This research and citation exercise measures your mastery of ULO 3.1. Your Expository Essay assignment requires that you use at least one academic source from the CSU Online Library, so this assignment will help you navigate the CSU Online Library’s webpage and resources in order to improve your information literacy,

Majoring in business continuation from 591922 Assignment Objective Your goal in this assignment is to write an expository essay in the style described in Units VI and VII. As discussed in Unit VI L

Majoring in business continuation from 591922 Assignment Objective Your goal in this assignment is to write an expository essay in the style described in Units VI and VII. As discussed in Unit VI Lesson I, the expository essay is a general term for an essay that conveys information to the

This research and citation exercise measures your mastery of ULO 3.1. Your Expository Essay assignment requires that you use at least one academic source from the CSU Online Library, so this assign

I need a definition essay about home roughly a page and half to two pages w/ paragraphing, good sentence structure and works cited including dictionary if you use it

Assignment Objective Your goal in this assignment is to write a paper that explains a particular experience and the subsequent lesson or value illuminated by that experience. The Narrative Essay al

Assignment Objective Your goal in this assignment is to write a paper that explains a particular experience and the subsequent lesson or value illuminated by that experience. The Narrative Essay allows you to become comfortable with academic writing while still employing first-person perspective; you must use precise illustrations to detail

Answer the following four questions. Responses should be between about a paragraph for each question. When we receive and inspect items, specifically high-protein foods, such as eggs, poultry, dairy p

Answer the following four questions. Responses should be between about a paragraph for each question. When we receive and inspect items, specifically high-protein foods, such as eggs, poultry, dairy products, seafood, and meats, there are certain best practices that should be in place. Please identify these best practices and how

Week 3: Event Description (100 points). Please provide the name of the event and a review of your concept and theme. Discuss the expectations of the event coordinators, client, attendees, and other st

Week 3: Event Description (100 points). Please provide the name of the event and a review of your concept and theme. Discuss the expectations of the event coordinators, client, attendees, and other stakeholders. What are their goals? Then, review how you will meet those goals. Describe the concept and theme that

Break Down the Barrier Read Incident 1 “Break Down the Barrier” question 11-25 Submission Instructions: The essay is to be clear and concise, and students will lose points for improper grammar, pu

Break Down the Barrier Read Incident 1 “Break Down the Barrier” question 11-25 Submission Instructions: The essay is to be clear and concise, and students will lose points for improper grammar, punctuation, misspelling, and incorrect APA format. Your essay should be a minimum of 500 words in length, current APA

I need to fix this essay from AI and make it look like if I did it myself. Keep the same concept and follow the following directions. Your argumentative essay will be on a topic from the list of optio

I need to fix this essay from AI and make it look like if I did it myself. Keep the same concept and follow the following directions. Your argumentative essay will be on a topic from the list of options below. Consider your audiencefor this paper to be your peers.

Should Social Media Platforms Be More Strictly Regulated to Protect User Privacy, or Do Users Bear the Responsibility for Their Own Online Safety? In today’s interconnected world, social media platf I

Should Social Media Platforms Be More Strictly Regulated to Protect User Privacy, or Do Users Bear the Responsibility for Their Own Online Safety? In today’s interconnected world, social media platf It’s just a matter of putting it in MLA format and adjusting the answer, that is, the entire essay, in

This is a multiple assignment request for English Composition II. Please refer to the attached files for additional information on the assignments.

Answer the following four questions. Responses should be about a paragraph for each question. Please identify the three types of contaminants, and provide examples of each. (The word count criterion d

Answer the following four questions. Responses should be about a paragraph for each question. Please identify the three types of contaminants, and provide examples of each. (The word count criterion does not apply to this question.) What are the most common types of allergens? There are several employee behaviors that

Assignment Overview Focusing on the five senses analysis, describe how you would use a focus group to establish the correct design of an event (you may use any event of your choice). How would you use

Assignment Overview Focusing on the five senses analysis, describe how you would use a focus group to establish the correct design of an event (you may use any event of your choice). How would you use this focus group? What types of questions would you ask? How would you conduct

My Dream Job Based on the chapters you have read on Module 3: Lecture Materials & Resources page, you should be able to put together a job description from beginning to end. Try to consider a diff

My Dream Job Based on the chapters you have read on Module 3: Lecture Materials & Resources page, you should be able to put together a job description from beginning to end. Try to consider a different job title from the one you hold with your present employer, think about it as