Kibata

Sign In

Our Services

Get 15% Discount on your First Order

Order Now
[rank_math_breadcrumb]

Discussion

Please read the instruction careful. No AI . Good grade feedback.

You must post before seeing replies. Edit history will be available to instructors.

Due Aug 27 60 points

View Split Screen

All

Search entries or author…

Newest First

 Back to Week at a Glance
(

SHOW ME THE EVIDENCE!

In the 19th century, the term “snake oil salesman” referred to a person who traveled from town
to town making extravagant claims about their cure-all elixirs. They used deceptive practices to
sell their product but would leave town before angry and disappointed customers could get their
money back.

In our modern life, we are still bombarded with claims about products/treatments that promise to
improve our lives. “Experts” may claim that a cream will make your skin look younger, a mattress

(
LgRendition/AdobeStock_286639141.jpeg)

4
4

will cure your back pain issues, changing your child’s diet will cure their attention deficit disorder
(ADD), or supplements with “proprietary” ingredients will cause you to lose weight.

But have you stopped to consider if there is scientific evidence to support these claims? Or might
some of these claims be made by the modern-day equivalent of a snake oil salesman? Are they
aiming to make money by selling a product they know to be ineffective or trying to increase
website revenue by driving up website traffic? For any claim you come across, you should
consider if scientific procedures have been utilized to validate the claim.

Skepticism and critical thinking are closely related concepts, often intertwined in the pursuit of
understanding and evaluating claims, beliefs, and evidence. As such, a skeptic is someone who
requires evidence to accept a claim. A skeptic would look for answers to questions such as:

“What evidence exists to support the claim?”
“How was this tested?”
“Who tested this and what credentials do they have?”
“What are the repercussions of purchasing or believing in a method that will not deliver
results?”

In this Discussion, you will practice being a skeptic by critically evaluating a media claim for a
product. Is the product the modern-day equivalent of snake oil? For this course and beyond, you
will learn the skills to be a critical consumer of information.

RESOURCES
Be sure to review the Learning Resources before completing this activity.

Cozby, P. C., & Bates, S. C. (2024). Methods in behavioral
research (15th ed.). McGraw Hill.

Chapter 1, “Scientific Understanding of Behavior”

Willingham, E. (2012, Nov. 8). 10 questions to distinguish real
from fake science
(
questions-to-distinguish-real-from-fake-science/?sh=445868c6146c)
. Forbes.

questions-to-distinguish-real-from-fake-science/?
sh=445868c6146c

Stemwedel, J. D. (2011, Oct. 4). Drawing the line between science
and pseudo-science (

Readings 

To prepare:

Review Chapter 1.
Consider what you learned in the Learning Activity, Becoming a Skilled Consumer of
Research.
Locate a claim in the media about a product that promises a cure or an improvement for
some aspect of psychological or physical health that you are skeptical about and that
could potentially be an example of pseudoscience.

Sources to search: advertisements on social media (e.g., Facebook, Instagram),
infomercials on the internet, advertisements in television commercials. (If the claim
you find is on TV, you can usually also find it on YouTube.)
Potential topics: homeopathic cures, cures for ADD/ADHD or autism, apps/games to
improve memory, anti-aging serums, etc.

Evaluate the claim by applying the textbook’s bulleted list of six indicators of
pseudoscience claims, which was also included in the Learning Activity.

Untestable/Unrefuted
Imprecise, Biased, or Vague
Anecdotal/Testimonial Evidence

good-science/drawing-the-line-between-science-and-pseudo-science/)
. Scientific American.
good-science/drawing-the-line-between-science-and-pseudo-
science/

Walden University, LLC. (2024). Becoming a skilled consumer of
research (
media.waldenu.edu/2dett4d/Walden/PSYC/3003/bs/index.html)
[Interactive media]. Walden University Canvas.

Meyer, R. C. (Director). (2019). A student’s guide to critical thinking
(

critical-thinking) [Video]. Alexander Street.

critical-thinking

Optional Media 

Questionable Expertise/Credentials
Confirmatory Evidence/Bias
Unverifiable Evidence

Assess the potential harmful psychological and/or physical effects or outcomes for
consumers of this product.

Post a response to the following.

In the first line of your post, state the claim you evaluated (e.g., Exercise app promises
weight loss in 30 days).

Provide a link (URL) to the claim you evaluated. If there is not a link, you may provide a
screenshot as an attachment to your post.
In one short paragraph, summarize the topic and claim that is made.
Explain at least two indicators of pseudoscience that made you skeptical of the claim.
Explain at least two potential harmful psychological or physical effects for consumers of
this claim.

Note: Your initial response should be supported with scholarly evidence from your research
and/or the Learning Resources and properly cited in APA format. You may state your opinion
and/or provide personal examples; however, you must also back up your assertions with
evidence, including in-text citation(s) and reference(s) in APA style. It is recommended that
you review the Grading Rubric with the criteria that will be used to evaluate your Discussion
prior to your submission.

Respond to the initial post of at least one colleague who picked a different topic than you.
Identify another potential indicator of pseudoscience present in the claim or an additional
harmful effect. Support your colleague reply with evidence from the assigned Learning
Resources. Provide a reference list for the resources you used.

Note: For this Discussion, you are required to complete your initial post before
you will be able to view and respond to your colleagues’ postings. Begin by
clicking on the Reply button to complete your initial post. Remember, once you
click on Post Reply, you cannot delete or edit your own posts and you cannot
post anonymously. Please check your post carefully before clicking on Post
Reply!

BY DAY 3

BY DAY 5

Reply

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Order Now

Related Questions

resp 3

attached Response to your classmate: Post 2- Self-management. Another evidence-based intervention that can be used in a school setting is self-management intervention. Smith et al. (2022) found positive results in a systematic review for the self-management procedures in all grades, improving behaviors and students’ academic growth. A self-management procedure will

resp 4

attched Response to your classmate Post 1: One effective RTI strategy is progress monitoring. This approach helps teachers keep track of how well students are learning after an intervention begins. It involves using short and frequent checks such as reading or math assessments to measure improvement over time. For instance,

dis 2

attached Rules for Discussion 2 – RTI and EBP  Each student is to make a minimum of 2 substantive posts and 2 replies.  Canvas often groups posts and I will respond to posts of the same topic. So, I may not be able to respond to each and every post,

Psychology

Write the paper how a entry level college student would write it You have been given a grant to study one of these five personality traits: openness to experience, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, and neuroticism. ● Define and describe the personality trait you chose. ● How might this personality trait be

week 3 discussion program

  Now that you have selected one measurable outcome from your logic model (Week 2), this week we will determine how the evaluation will be conducted and who will be included in it. For this discussion, address the following: 1. Outcome Being Evaluated State one short-term or intermediate outcome from

DQ

see attached Discussion Board #8: Informative Speech Organization Examples LAST WEEK:  You browsed through examples of informative presentations to get a sense of the presenter’s type of speech, subject choice, and purpose. Now, we’ll use the organizational information introduced during the PK presentations to build your understanding of how presentations

Yes or NO

see attached  Read Cluster 14 in your text as well as the cluster 14 power point. Then submit your typed response to the Homework assignment by the due date listed. Homework Yes or No Do you think homework should be assigned? Whether you say yes or no, provide an explanation

L&CP Week 3 Assignment

Instructions Respond to the following questions. What is the importance, if any, of officer intent and motive in the “objective standard of reasonable force” under the current state of the law? Contrast the definition of probable cause with that of reasonable suspicion. Complete the following questions: Compare and contrast Fourth

Controversial Treatments Chelation Therapy

  1 Controversial Treatments: Reflection Paper and Video Presentation Liadanay Velazquez Department of Social and Behavioral Sciences, Capella University PSY7710: Ethics in Applied Behavior Analysis Instructor Name Assignment Due Date Controversial Treatments: Reflection Paper and Video Presentation (Please note, all italicized writing in this template is for instructional purposes. You

psychology

PSYC 320 Behavior Modification Project: Baseline Phase Report Assignment Instructions Overview To assess your baseline as you begin the experiment, you need to observe your target behavior before you ever treat it or try to modify it – in other words do not change anything you do. Thus, you will

psych brain functioning (Les)

Module 3: Critical Thinking/Application Prompts     Instructions Each week, you will be presented with a series of critical thinking prompts and application prompts. Please copy/paste the prompts into an offline document (Word, for example) and compose your responses offline (be sure to save your work).  Then click on the “Submit

Psychology week two assignment

  Hi Barbara, Nice start with clear outcomes. As you draft Section 1 of your assignment, just remember to include some credible statistics describing the scope of the problem the program addresses.

Feedback keiland

       If the CHANCE program were highly successful, success would mean that adolescents who are survivors of human trafficking experience lasting emotional healing, safety, and self-sufficiency. Youth would show stronger self-worth, consistent school or job engagement, and the ability to form trusting relationships with supportive adults. Families and foster caregivers

psych wk 2 less

Main post (due Friday, November 7, by 11:59 PM):  leslie Please read the following information related to concussions and then answer the questions below: The brain sits in the cranium, surrounded by cerebral fluid. When a severe blow to the head occurs, the brain may collide with the cranium, then

Social Media

I need help understanding the paragraph format Overview In this assignment, you will write a 3–5 page paper on the effects of social media on the developing mind. Preparation Topic Selection Choose one of the following topics: · Internet use among elementary age children (ages 5–11). · Social media use

psychology

Behavior Modification Project: Research Paper Assignment Instructions Overview You will write a 4-6-page, current APA formatted, research paper that will aid you in the Behavior Modification Project. You should reference your textbook and at least 6 additional peer-reviewed empirical research journal articles. The research paper will include a title page,

assitant needed E Kenniqua

Shared Writing: Psychological Disorders One of your authors once attended a training session where the instructor shared that they did not believe in the DSM or in using diagnoses. This person believed that diagnoses were much like rumors in that they had the potential to lead toward specific beliefs and

Week 11

Post a brief description of the culture in which you immersed yourself. Next, explain how the Immersion Project assisted you in understanding and respecting other cultures in general and helped you further develop cultural humility.