Kibata

Sign In

Our Services

Get 15% Discount on your First Order

Order Now
[rank_math_breadcrumb]

Identify 3 flaws in the research design that might impact the validity, reliability, and generalizability of the research outcomes.

Purpose of the Assignment:

  • The purpose of this assignment is to have you evaluate sociological research design. You will do this by identifying flaws and proposing solutions to those flaws in validity, reliability, and generalizability found in the research methodology of the provided research scenario. You will also demonstrate your sociological understanding of groups and leadership. 
  • Through this assignment, you will practice skills necessary to evaluate research you could possibly come across in real-world situations (in the news, social media, in current/future jobs, etc…). 

Research Scenario:

  • Here are the results of a rather poorly designed sociology study that investigated group leadership dynamics. The study suffered from significant methodological flaws, limiting the reliability and generalizability of the findings. The researcher chose a small convenience sample from personal friends. The sample had 8 women and 3 men. Participants were given a brief questionnaire with open-ended questions and no survey. None of the participants was a group leader themselves. Each participant defined “group” and “leadership” according to their own personal understanding of the terms. Despite these limitations, the study reported some preliminary observations, which should be interpreted with caution. 

Group Leadership Styles

  • The study explored different leadership styles observed within groups. Based on self-report questionnaires, participants reported a mix of authoritarian, democratic, and laissez-faire leadership styles in their groups. No definitions of these leadership styles were provided to participants.

Communication Patterns

  • Participants provided anecdotal evidence of various communication patterns within their groups. Some groups reported open and effective communication, fostering collaboration and decision-making. Conversely, others mentioned challenges with communication, such as dominance of certain members or lack of participation. (Anecdotal
    evidence is personal stories that are collected because they seem interesting and related to the topic.)

Group Cohesion

  • The study assessed group cohesion by asking participants to describe their
    perceived sense of unity and cooperation within their groups. The results indicated a range of
    experiences, with some groups reporting high levels of cohesion and others reporting low levels.

Impact of Leadership on Group Performance

  • Participants were asked about the perceived impact of leadership on group performance. While some participants believed that effective leadership positively influenced group outcomes, others reported no significant relationship
    between leadership and performance. There was no standardized measurement of performance.

Gender and Leadership

  • The study explored the potential influence of gender on leadership dynamics within the groups. participants provided subjective accounts of gender-related experiences in the workplace, including stereotypes and biases they think might impact leadership roles.

Results of this Study

  • The study only provides preliminary and insufficient insights into group leadership dynamics. Future research with improved research methods is necessary to deepen our understanding of group leadership and its impact on various outcomes.

  • Introduction (Paragraph 1): Identify 3 flaws in the research design that might impact the validity, reliability, and generalizability of the research outcomes. Explain why they are flaws. Define all terms and concepts (use your materials and in-text citations).
  • Flaw 1 (Paragraph 2): describe how the research design could be improved to address and eliminate flaw 1  (use your materials and in-text citations).  
  • Flaw 2 (Paragraph 3): describe how the research design could be improved to address and eliminate flaw 2  (use your materials and in-text citations).  
  • Flaw 3 (Paragraph 4): describe how the research design could be improved to address and eliminate flaw 3  (use your materials and in-text citations).  
  • Conclusion (Paragraph 5): Answer the following questions.
    • What do you think would be a good way to study group leadership dynamics?
    • What aspects of groups and leadership do you think are the most important to study?
    • What specific research methodologies would you choose?

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Order Now

Related Questions

Discussion

  After listening to the NPR podcast, define what is going on in a more behaviorally appropriate manner. (Note: You must include ALL required readings for this week and include 1 outside reference to earn full credit! Also remember you must respond to peer to earn full credit.)

Social Science – Sociology Assignment 2

Please see attached File  Imagine these two scenarios: First, a man stumbles out of a bar, speaking loudly, trying to gain the attention of passersby by putting his arm around them to start a conversation, or remarking on the dress of another passerby. Second, a man stands outside the public

Social Science – Sociology Assignment 1

Please see attached File For citizens in some countries, religious oppression is common and long-standing. Although freedom of religion is protected in the United States, religious intolerance and discrimination remain. Consider Islamophobia and the backlash against those of the Muslim faith following the 9/11 terrorist attacks. Social workers must be

BEHS495 WEEK 1 POST HELP

HELP ASAP BEHS 495 WEEK 1 LEARNING RESOURCES Samples of Research Posters · Power Point Presentation – Poster Example · Power Point Presentation – Model Poster 1 · Power Point Presentation – Model Poster 2 · Power Point Presentation – Model Poster 3 · Power Point Presentation – Model Poster

Social Science – Sociology BEHS495 ASSIGNMENT 1

HELP ASAP BEHS495 ASSIGNMENT 1 What is Interdisciplinarity? Top of Form Hide Assignment Information Turnitin™ This assignment will be submitted to Turnitin™. Instructions Week 1   Assignment: What is Interdisciplinarity? (50 points, 5% of final grade)  Purpose: This assignment helps you clarify your understanding of interdisciplinarity and how to approach an interdisciplinary

PSYC338 UNIT 1 POST HELP

HELP ASAP PSYC338 UNIT 1 DISCUSSION Please consider the following prompt and craft a response that sufficiently captures all aspects of it from your unique point of view and original research. Please cite and reference any source(s) you use to help write this response in  APA format . Notice that

Comm Final Project

See Attached · Revise each slide you have already completed in the milestone submissions, incorporating the feedback you have received from your instructor. · Add the following slides to your final presentation: · Slide 7: “Effectiveness” (Critical Element V below) · Slide 8: “Recommendations” (Critical Element VI below) · Slide

Social Media

See Attached Select a social media platform and discuss its influence relating to photography. · What is the platform’s impact on photography? · How has its use of photographs made the world smaller? · Does the way the platform is designed alter the way that users imagine or experience their

Leveraging Cost Volume Profit Analysis

How do you leverage the information obtained through cost volume profit (CVP) analysis to determine the goods and services provided to consumers? Please justify your response. The following resource may help you visualize how changes and input variables affect the profit and loss scenario:

need help

will say when accepted 1. Analysis of Social Work Purpose and Values: Due Friday, November 1st, 2024 Value: 40% of Final Grade – 10 pages, including title page and references The purpose of this assignment is for you to demonstrate the application of some of the principles of social work

Social Science – Sociology Assignment

Please see attached file Up to this point in the course, you have been looking at each dimension of diversity on its own. However, these dimensions do not exist in isolation. Rather, they sit alongside and on top of one another, intersecting and shaping a person’s unique identity and contributing

Short Response

Instructions · Search for a peer-reviewed journal article (2010-2021) on group treatment for substance use disorders Areas to cover in your paper: This is a 3 -4 page paper (not including cover page and reference page) will address how the peer-reviewed journal article aligns with the course content. · Summarize

Discussion

  Describe either your best training experience, OR your worst training experience.  For your best training experience, what elements of BST were included? What did they do that made you enjoy the training?

Social Science – Sociology Community Credit Assignment

  For this assignment, you will engage in a reflective analysis of a community event of your choice from a sociological perspective. The goal of this assignment is to apply sociological concepts and theories to understand the dynamics, interactions, and social structures that occur during the event. You will critically

Social Science – Sociology Assignment

Please see attached file Has your community changed its street corners to ramps with tactile warning devices (i.e., the “bumps” on the ramps)? This is a visible implementation of the Americans With Disabilities Act. Accessible building entrances are another. When observing a wheelchair user access a building or a visually

Social Science – Sociology Assignment

Please see attachment  SOCIAL CLASS Social class extends beyond wealth and other financial indicators. Class also includes details like the amount of free time enjoyed, quality of life, educational attainment, and others’ perceptions of social status. The language and experience of class is woven into everyday communications and judgments. For

SOCIAL SCIENCE WEEK 8 POST RESPONSE 2

HELP ASAP POST REPLY INSTRUCTIONS Note: In your responses to classmates this week, please answer the following questions: What was most interesting to you about your classmate’s project? What one suggestion would you make to your classmate?  For example, is there information or ideas that need to be further clarified?