please read all instructions
Major Paper: Theories on Organizational Communication and Management
TEXTBOOK(S) AND REQUIRED MATERIALS: Title: Organizational Communication: Balancing Creativity and Constraint Author: Eric Eisenberg, H.L. Goodall Jr, Angela Trethewey, and Marianne Legreco Publisher: Bedford/St. Martin’s
Year Published: 2016 Edition: 8th
ISBN: 10: 1319052347 or 13: 978-1319052348
For your Research Paper you need to research on any four theories of your choice, from chapters three, four, five or six, and write an 11 – 12 paper, including the reference page, but excluding the cover page. You do NOT need to write an abstract, just start with the introduction. Because this is an academic appear, you have to include an introduction and a conclusion. Please do not include graphs, pictures, bullets, or lists. Rather all your text should be presented as full sentences in an essay format.
Please make sure your paper covers the following:
1. A clear definition of the theory that you have chosen – please find different literature sources, such as books, or journal articles from which to find definitions. From the definitions that you include in your paper, select the one which you think best describes the theory that you have selected.
2. A description of this theory in detail, – again, use several literature sources. Here also include the formulator or propounder, when it was formulated. Remember theories are historical – therefore given the historical circumstances of this theory; how does this theory explain organizational communication of that particular period?
3. An evaluation of that theory – to what extent does it explain organizational communication well? What are some of the criticisms against those theories?
4. An identification of organizations which best embody organizational communication theory as explained through the lenses of those theories
IMPORTANT POINT OF CLARIFICATION: Please follow steps 1 – 4 for all the four theories that you would have chosen. However please apply at least one theory to your personal experiences.
Your paper should be written as a college paper; meaning that it should be double-spaced, spell-checked, with correct grammar. It should include 6-8 academic citation sources and formatted using APA 7TH edition.
A research guide for a major paper
For your major paper, I would like you to use this guide to help you through the process, from the time of selecting your topic to citing your sources.
Step One: Select your topic or issue
Whenever you have an option of selecting a topic, the rule of thumb is to select a topic which is close to your heart. You will likely find it easier to research on, write about; it will more likely be useful to you and your readers; and you will also enjoy the writing process!
Step Two: Search for terms
You need to locate journal articles and books on this topic.
a) Google Scholar
You can also use Google Scholar to find citation sources with. To use Google Scholar, go to Google, type Google Scholar, then type the key terms of your research , and include the term “communication” to make sure that the sources are focused on communication
To search your topic, use the appropriate terms for example:
McGregor’s Theory Y AND communication
General Systems Theory AND communication
The Learning Organization Theory AND communication
Critical Theory AND communication
Step Three: Look for different viewpoints on your topic
Step Four: Select only credible academic sources. In other words, if it’s a journal article, it has to be peer reviewed. When you search, you need to include in the search engine that you are looking for peer-reviewed sources. Only use journal articles which are nine years or younger.
Step Five: When you find articles that are suitable for your topic, go to the Discussion session, or Conclusions and get your information from there.
Step Six: Use the information from the Results and Conclusions sections as Examples in making your argument. Also use statistics generated by the authors in the journal articles which you would have reviewed.
Step Seven: Use the APA 7th citation format in your paper
A Few Reminders About In-text citations:
1) Remember in in-text citations, you do not include the initial of the author, you just include the last name of the author and the year, for example it’s (Johns, 2021), not (Johns, M, 2021)
Major Paper – Theories Rubric |
||||||
|
Poor (1) |
Below Average (2) |
Average (3) |
Above Average (4) |
Excellent (5) |
|
Giving at least one definition for each theory, showing exactly what the theory is and what the major concepts or components (parts) of that theory |
Does not adequately define each of the theories |
May describe each theory, but the definition lacks significant detail. |
Correctly and adequately defines each theory. However, descriptions from the textbook are not used. |
Correctly defines each theory from just one source briefly mention the major components of the theory. |
Correctly defines each theory from at least two fresh sources*, briefly mention the major components of the theory and also uses concepts from the textbook. |
|
Thoroughly discussing each theory using views from different literature sources, highlighting the history of each theory, where it has been applied, showing the strengths, weaknesses of each theory, how each theory has been criticized.
|
Does not correctly describe each theory, its history, or where it can be used or has been used |
Only discusses each theory without giving its historical context |
Correctly discusses all the characteristics of each theory, using a minimum of three sources. The history of the theory is included. |
Correctly discusses all the characteristics of each theory, using a minimum of three sources. Properly identifies its history, strengths, weaknesses, where has been applied or can be applied. |
Correctly discusses all the characteristics of each theory, using a minimum of three sources. Properly identifies its history, strengths, weaknesses, where has been applied or can be applied. In discussing the theory’s history, the organizational communication context, or society, or problem explained by the theory is clearly identified |
|
Giving clear examples of different organizations where each theory can be applied |
Does not give any examples of any organization, applicable to each theory |
Dos not correctly apply a theory to an organization |
Correctly applies specific components examples showing complete understanding of the organization’s operations. The operations of the organization do not reflect any of the theories |
Correctly applies specific examples showing complete understanding of the organization’s operations, and how these reflect the theories chosen. Does not include personal, experience of the theory |
Correctly applies specific components examples showing complete understanding of the organization’s operations, and how these reflect the theories chosen, including discussing personal experiences of the theory. This section uses at least one source or more |
2) In a narrative citation, the author’s name is used within the text of the sentence; whereas a parenthetical citation is a type of citation where the author and date are in parentheses at the end of the sentence, for example Johns (2021) explains how to make sandwiches using green carrots.
3) In a parenthetical citation, you put the information about the source in parentheses at the end of a sentence or in the text, for example: Making sandwiches using green carrots has become a nutritional boost for most older Americans (Johns, 2021).
4) Only use direct quotes if the essence of what you want to convey would be lost if paraphrased.
5) If you use direct quotes, you are required to include a page number or paragraph number in the citation. For example, leading health experts argue “how making sandwiches with green carrots gives added nutrition to people 65 years and above” (Johns, 2021, p.261).
6) When your citation has 39 words or less, place quotation marks around the quote. If however the citation is 40 words or more, indent the quotation, and exclude quotation marks.
7) Most importantly, your citation should not be sitting by itself as an isolated piece of information in your paper. Rather, you need to integrate it within the point that you will be making.
8) For all the sources in your reference page, in-text citations should be used inside the paper.
Structure |
The reflection (thoughtful review of the concept) is missing. The introduction and conclusion is nonexistent. |
The introduction clearly lacks one or two of the requirements. The reflection portion is cursory. The conclusion is not structured in any relevant sense. |
May be lacking parts of the introduction, or the reflection portion is inadequate and/or the conclusion is lacking structure. |
Properly uses a hook (attention device), states a clear thesis, and previews the major sections of the paper. Generates interesting and accurate reflections. The conclusion is structured with a summary |
Properly uses a hook (attention device), states a clear thesis, and previews the major sections of the paper. Generates interesting and accurate reflections. The conclusion is structured with a summary. In addition, you demonstrate unique creativity and/or thoughtfulness in the presentation. |
|
Grammar, Presentation, Style, Citing (APA, 7TH edition) |
Clearly does not follow the requirements or any standard conventions of writing. Grammar and typographic errors get in the way of comprehension. Reference page is not submitted. |
Less than satisfactory presentation. Does not adhere to the requirements. Grammar and typographic errors are distracting. Reference page may or may not have been turned in. |
Adequate presentation. Proofreading is suspect. Proper in-text citation and references may be used. Quite a few grammar or typographic errors. Reference page may or may not have been turned in. |
Adequate presentation. Clearly has been proofread. Proper in-text citation and references are used. Few grammar or typographic errors. |
Good presentation. Clearly has been proofread. Proper in-text citation and citations are used correctly without error. Extraordinarily few if any grammar or typographic errors. |
|
Paper and Electronic Version |
Paper is not turned in. |
Paper is more than three days late. |
Paper is two days late. |
Paper is one day late. |
Paper is turned in on time. |
*The sources here are for each section. However the total number of sources required for the paper remains 6-8.
Adapted from
Armfield, G. G. (2017). Organizational Culture Analysis. New Mexico State University. Retrieved from
on August 29, 2021