Finish the worksheet.
Due Tuesday by 11:59pm
Points 50
Submitting a file upload
File Types doc, docx, pdf, and rtf
Critical Reading Worksheet
Start Assignment
ARTH 3010
WORKSHEET: CRITICAL READING
INSTRUCT IONS
Be sure to watch this week’s lectures
( in preparation
for completing the Critical Reading Worksheet–they will help prepare you for the assignment!
Click Here to Download: ARTH 3010 Critical Reading Worksheet
(
(
Download the worksheet linked above & fill it out to the best of your ability. Reach out to your
instructor or TA if you have questions!
Once you have completed all of the sections, please save & retitle the file with your name
(e.g. “YourName_CriticalReading.docx”)
Upload your file to this assignment to submit.
2024/9/2 13:18 Module 3: Critical Reading Worksheet
1/3
Criteria Ratings Pts
10 pts
10 pts
10 pts
10 pts
Thesis 10 to >9.0 pts
Excellent
Correctly identifies
and
comprehensively
describes the
author’s primary
thesis.
9 to >8.0 pts
Good
Correctly
identifies the
author’s primary
thesis, but
description may
be overly
general or miss
a minor aspect
of the argument.
8 to >7.0 pts
Needs
Improvement
Identifies an
important
element of the
author’s
argument but
may miss the
primary thesis.
7 to >1.0 pts
Poor
Fails to
identify the
thesis of the
article.
1 to >0 pts
Insufficient
No
response
submitted.
Visual
Evidence
10 to >9.0 pts
Excellent
Correctly
identifies and
thoroughly
describes 2
specific
instances of
visual analysis
(for 2 different
works of art)
used to support
the
interpretation.
9 to >8.0 pts
Good
Correctly
identifies and
describes 2
specific
instances of
visual analysis
(for 2 different
works of art)
used to support
the
interpretation,
but descriptions
may not be
thorough.
8 to >7.0 pts
Needs
Improvement
Identifies and
describes 2
specific
instances of
visual analysis
(for 2 different
works of art), but
may not clearly
relate these to
the thesis and/or
descriptions may
be incomplete.
7 to >1.0 pts
Poor
Does not
identify and/or
describe 2
instances of
visual analysis
for 2 different
works of art.
1 to >0 pts
Insufficient
No
response
submitted.
Historical
Evidence
10 to >9.0 pts
Excellent
Correctly
identifies and
thoroughly
describes 2
specific pieces
of evidence
used to support
the
interpretation.
9 to >8.0 pts
Good
Correctly
identifies and
describes 2
specific pieces
of evidence used
to support the
interpretation,
but descriptions
may not be
thorough.
8 to >7.0 pts
Needs
Improvement
Identifies and
describes 2
specific pieces of
evidence, but
some
identifications
may be unrelated
to the thesis
and/or
descriptions may
be incomplete.
7 to >1.0 pts
Poor
Does not
identify and/or
describe 2
pieces of
evidence.
1 to >0 pts
Insufficient
No
response
submitted.
Sources 10 to >9.0 pts
Excellent
Lists two source
texts and
successfully
9 to >8.0 pts
Good
Lists two source
texts but may
have minor
8 to >7.0 pts
Needs
Improvement
Lists two source
texts but has
7 to >1.0 pts
Poor
Does not list
two source
texts, and/or
1 to >0 pts
Insufficient
No
response
submitted.
2024/9/2 13:18 Module 3: Critical Reading Worksheet
2/3
Total Points: 50
Criteria Ratings Pts
10 pts
relates each to
the argument of
the text.
lapses in
relating them to
the argument of
the text.
difficulty relating
them to the
argument of the
text.
has major
difficulty relating
them to the
argument of the
text.
Conclusions 10 to >9.0 pts
Excellent
Thoughtfully
reflects on the
author’s success
in defending their
thesis, and
comprehensively
describes how
they reached their
conclusion.
9 to >8.0 pts
Good
Reflects on the
author’s
success in
defending their
thesis, and
describes how
they reached
their
conclusion.
Reflection and
description
may be general
or superficial.
8 to >7.0 pts
Needs
Improvement
Either the
reflection on the
author’s
success in
defending their
thesis or the
description of
how they
reached their
conclusion may
be absent or
overly difficult to
comprehend.
7 to >1.0 pts
Poor
Does not
reflect on the
author’s
success in
defending their
thesis, and
does not
describe how
they reached
their
conclusion.
1 to >0 pts
Insufficient
No
response
submitted.
2024/9/2 13:18 Module 3: Critical Reading Worksheet
3/3